Abstract
Objective
Describe cross-cultural differences in nutrition-related factors among adolescents from São Paulo, Brazil and St Paul–Minneapolis, US.
Design
Two large-population-based studies with cross-cultural comparisons.
Setting
Twelve São Paulo and 10 St Paul–Minneapolis high schools in 2009–2010.
Participants
A total of 1,148 adolescents from São Paulo and 1,632 adolescents from St Paul–Minneapolis.
Main Outcome Measure(s)
Meal consumption, family meals, fast-food consumption, and home food availability.
Analysis
Binomial regressions, weighted for age distributions and adjusted for gender, were used to compare identical measures from each sample.
Results
Generally, São Paulo adolescents reported healthier nutritional outcomes than St Paul–Minneapolis adolescents. São Paulo adolescents were 7 times less likely to report high fast-food consumption than St Paul–Minneapolis adolescents (P < .001). Whereas most measures of the home environment indicated healthier home environments in São Paulo, more São Paulo adolescents reported that sugar-sweetened beverages were usually available at home than did St Paul–Minneapolis adolescents (P < .001).
Conclusions and Implications
São Paulo youth tended to have healthier eating behaviors and home food environment factors than St Paul–Minneapolis youth. Brazilian eating patterns tend to be healthier and support a connection with food and culture. Interventions are needed to encourage youth and their families to maintain these patterns.
Introduction
In Brazil, as in other countries within Latin America, nutritional transitions have been observed, resulting in an emergence of overnutrition and increased risk for childhood overweight/obesity.
1Global nutrition dynamics: the world is shifting rapidly toward a diet linked with non-communicable diseases.
National data indicate that the prevalence of overweight status among Brazilian youth has tripled in girls and has increased 6-fold in boys during the 30-year period from 1975 to 2002.
2- Monteiro C.A.
- D'A Benicio M.H.
- Conde W.L.
- Popkin B.M.
Shifting obesity trends in Brazil.
Secular trends show that the traditional diets in Brazil, characterized by rice and beans, have been rapidly replaced by industrialized foods, which are rich in sugar, salt, fat, and empty calories.
1Global nutrition dynamics: the world is shifting rapidly toward a diet linked with non-communicable diseases.
, 2- Monteiro C.A.
- D'A Benicio M.H.
- Conde W.L.
- Popkin B.M.
Shifting obesity trends in Brazil.
, 3Obesity trends and determinant factors in Latin America.
, 4Nutrition transition: a review of Latin American profile.
, 5- Levy-Costa R.B.
- Sichieri R.
- Pontes N.
- Monteiro C.A.
Household food availability in Brazil: distribution and trends (1974–2003).
, 6Nutrition and global prevention on non-communicable diseases.
, 7- Schmidt M.I.
- Duncan B.B.
- Azevedo e Silva G.
- et al.
Chronic non-communicable diseases in Brazil: burden and current challenges.
, 8- Larson N.I.
- Neumark-Sztainer D.R.
- Harnack L.J.
- Wall M.M.
- Story M.T.
- Eisenberg M.E.
Fruit and vegetable intake correlates during the transition to young adulthood.
, 9- Befort C.
- Kaur H.
- Nollen N.
- et al.
Fruit, vegetable, and fat intake among non-Hispanic black and non-Hispanic white adolescents: associations with home availability and food consumption settings.
Worldwide, adolescents generally report low consumption of fruits and vegetables, skipping meals, consuming a large portion of their diet from fast-food restaurants, and not having family meals.
10- Bauer K.W.
- Larson N.I.
- Nelson M.C.
- Story M.
- Neumark-Sztainer D.
Socio-environmental, personal and behavioral predictors of fast food intake among adolescents.
, 11- Albertson A.M.
- Franko D.L.
- Thompson D.
- et al.
Longitudinal patterns of breakfast eating in black and white adolescent girls.
, 12- Neumark-Sztainer D.
- Larson N.I.
- Fulkerson J.A.
- Eisenberg M.E.
- Story M.
Family meals and adolescents: what have we learned from Project EAT.
, 13- Burgess-Champoux T.L.
- Larson N.
- Neumark-Sztainer D.
- Hannan P.J.
- Story M.
Are family meal patterns associated with overall diet quality during the transition from early to middle adolescence?.
Research has indicated that the home food environment may contribute to adolescent eating behaviors.
9- Befort C.
- Kaur H.
- Nollen N.
- et al.
Fruit, vegetable, and fat intake among non-Hispanic black and non-Hispanic white adolescents: associations with home availability and food consumption settings.
Little is known about eating behaviors and the home food environment among Brazilian youth, and how these compare to those of US youth, who are exposed to a more “advanced” stage of the nutrition transition.
14- Drewnowski A.
- Popkin B.M.
The nutrition transition: new trends in the global diet.
, 15- Batista Filho M.
- Souza A.I.
- Miglioli T.C.
- Santos M.C.
Anemia and obesity: a paradox of the nutritional transition in Brazil.
, 16Are child eating patterns being transformed globally?.
, 17- Stein A.D.
- Thompson A.M.
- Waters A.
Childhood growth and chronic disease: evidence from countries undergoing the nutrition transition.
, 18- Lock K.
- Smith R.D.
- Dangour A.D.
- et al.
Health, agricultural, and economic effects of adoption of healthy diet recommendations.
, 19Globalization of food patterns and cardiovascular disease risk.
, 20Instituto Brasileiro de Geografia e Estatística. Household Budget Survey 2008–2009. Pesquisa de orçamentos familiares 2008-2009. Anthropometry and nutritional status of children, adolescents and adults in Brazil. Rio de Janeiro, Brazil; 2010.
, 21Contemporary nutritional transition: Determinants of diet and its impact on body composition.
Identifying similarities and differences across these 2 distinct cultures can help in understanding the types of factors that may influence current eating patterns and health outcomes of Brazilian youth, and inform the development of interventions to prevent a progression to problems prevalent among US youth. For example, differences across countries may suggest the importance of local influences (eg, local food availability, cultural patterns), whereas similarities may suggest more global influences (eg, media, fast–food chains).
15- Batista Filho M.
- Souza A.I.
- Miglioli T.C.
- Santos M.C.
Anemia and obesity: a paradox of the nutritional transition in Brazil.
, 16Are child eating patterns being transformed globally?.
, 17- Stein A.D.
- Thompson A.M.
- Waters A.
Childhood growth and chronic disease: evidence from countries undergoing the nutrition transition.
, 18- Lock K.
- Smith R.D.
- Dangour A.D.
- et al.
Health, agricultural, and economic effects of adoption of healthy diet recommendations.
, 19Globalization of food patterns and cardiovascular disease risk.
, 20Instituto Brasileiro de Geografia e Estatística. Household Budget Survey 2008–2009. Pesquisa de orçamentos familiares 2008-2009. Anthropometry and nutritional status of children, adolescents and adults in Brazil. Rio de Janeiro, Brazil; 2010.
, 21Contemporary nutritional transition: Determinants of diet and its impact on body composition.
Thus, the purpose of this article is to describe similarities and differences in eating behaviors and home food environmental factors in 2 large metropolitan samples of adolescents living in São Paulo, Brazil and St Paul–Minneapolis, US. It was hypothesized that adolescents from São Paulo would, in general, have healthier behaviors and a healthier home food environment, such as reporting lower consumption and home availability of unhealthy foods, less meal skipping, and higher frequency of family meals.
Results
São Paulo adolescents reported consuming breakfast, lunch, and family meals significantly more often than St Paul–Minneapolis youth (
Table 1). For example, 69% of São Paulo adolescents regularly consumed breakfast (at least 5 times/wk) compared with 47% of St Paul–Minneapolis adolescents (
P < .001). Similarly, 50% of São Paulo youth reported having family meals at least 5 times/wk, compared with 40% of St Paul–Minneapolis youth (
P < .001). São Paulo youth also reported significantly less fast-food intake than St Paul–Minneapolis youth; only 3% of São Paulo adolescents had fast food on a regular basis, compared with 21% of St Paul–Minneapolis adolescents (
P < .001).
Table 1Frequency of Meal Consumption, Family Meals, and Fast Food in Past Week Among Adolescents From São Paulo and St Paul–Minneapolis
Note: t tests were used for continuous nonadjusted variables, chi-square tests were used for categorical nonadjusted variables, and binomial regression was adjusted for gender and weighted for age.
All measures of home food availability were significantly different between São Paulo and St Paul–Minneapolis (
P < .001). In general, findings showed healthier home food environments in São Paulo, with greater fruit and vegetable availability and lower percentages of home with salty snacks readily available (
Table 2). In addition, 81% of São Paulo adolescents reported usually or always having milk served at meals, compared with only 37% of St Paul–Minneapolis adolescents. However, there were some notable exceptions; for example, 56% of São Paulo adolescents reported that sugar-sweetened beverages were usually available at home, compared with 44% of St Paul–Minneapolis adolescents.
Table 2Home Food Availability as Reported by Adolescents in São Paulo and St Paul–Minneapolis
Note: t tests were used for continuous nonadjusted variables, chi-square tests were used for categorical nonadjusted variables, and binomial regression was adjusted for gender and weighted for age.
Discussion
This cross-cultural study was designed to compare eating behaviors and home food availability across adolescents living in 2 different cultural, socioeconomic, and physical locations. The researchers found differences that generally indicated that adolescents from São Paulo had healthier nutrition-related factors than adolescents from St Paul–Minneapolis. These differences suggest that local influences may influence healthier eating patterns in Brazil. However, across countries there were also similarities, which suggests that concerns about poor eating patterns and obesity are pervasive across adolescents from different parts of the world. Findings have implications for understanding factors related to adolescent eating patterns and for the development of interventions to prevent the nutrition transition from getting worse in Brazil and for reversing unhealthy eating patterns among US youth.
Frequent consumption of fast food (at least 3 times/wk) was much lower among São Paulo adolescents (3%) than St Paul–Minneapolis adolescents (21%). Previous US-based research indicates that regular consumption of fast food is associated with poorer dietary outcomes such as higher intakes of sodium, and saturated fat.
31O fast food e a mundialização do gosto.
, 32- Jaime P.C.
- Duran A.C.
- Sarti F.M.
- Lock K.
Investigating environmental determinants of diet, physical activity, and overweight among adults in Sao Paulo, Brazil.
, 33- Lignani J.B.
- Sichieri R.
- Burlandy L.
- Salles-Costa R.
Changes in food consumption among the Programa Bolsa Família participant families in Brazil.
Although fast-food outlets have been in São Paulo for over 30 years,
34Instituto Brasileiro de Geografia e Estatística
National Household Budget Survey 2002–2003: Analyses on Household Food Availability and Nutrition Status in Brazil.
a recent Brazilian study found that fast-food restaurants tend to be expensive and low-income populations often do not have financial access to these outlets.
33- Lignani J.B.
- Sichieri R.
- Burlandy L.
- Salles-Costa R.
Changes in food consumption among the Programa Bolsa Família participant families in Brazil.
, 34Instituto Brasileiro de Geografia e Estatística
National Household Budget Survey 2002–2003: Analyses on Household Food Availability and Nutrition Status in Brazil.
Policy makers would be wise to prevent the widespread infiltration of fast-food restaurants in Brazil, to preserve the low intake of fast food found among youth in the current study, and in particular within its low-income neighborhoods, because with time, these populations may begin to eat at fast-food outlets more owing to factors such as convenience or social norms. In addition, low-income families receive financial support from the government in conditional cash transfer in Brazil, and recent studies have found that families receiving this financial support are eating foods not previously available to them. One recent study in Brazil found that families that received the conditional cash transfer changed their food intake, with an increase of processed foods and high energy–density foods.
33- Lignani J.B.
- Sichieri R.
- Burlandy L.
- Salles-Costa R.
Changes in food consumption among the Programa Bolsa Família participant families in Brazil.
Meal consumption and family meals were observed at a higher prevalence in São Paulo adolescents compared with St Paul–Minneapolis adolescents. Previous studies have shown the importance of having regular meals to prevent weight gain, improve cognition, and increase consumption of foods and nutrients typical to certain meals (eg, milk and calcium for breakfast).
11- Albertson A.M.
- Franko D.L.
- Thompson D.
- et al.
Longitudinal patterns of breakfast eating in black and white adolescent girls.
, 23- Larson N.
- Wall M.W.
- Story M.T.
- Neumark-Sztainer D.
Home/family, peer, school, and neighborhood correlates of obesity in adolescents.
Family meals offer an important opportunity to engage in healthier eating and to connect with other family members.
12- Neumark-Sztainer D.
- Larson N.I.
- Fulkerson J.A.
- Eisenberg M.E.
- Story M.
Family meals and adolescents: what have we learned from Project EAT.
Family meals have been found to be associated with a lower prevalence of unhealthy behaviors such as tobacco, alcohol, and drug use and engaging in unhealthy weight control behaviors such as self-induced vomiting and use of diet pills, laxatives, and diuretics.
12- Neumark-Sztainer D.
- Larson N.I.
- Fulkerson J.A.
- Eisenberg M.E.
- Story M.
Family meals and adolescents: what have we learned from Project EAT.
, 13- Burgess-Champoux T.L.
- Larson N.
- Neumark-Sztainer D.
- Hannan P.J.
- Story M.
Are family meal patterns associated with overall diet quality during the transition from early to middle adolescence?.
Although São Paulo youth tended to report healthier eating behaviors, they also reported a higher presence of sugar-sweetened beverages at home than did St Paul–Minneapolis youth. Although home food availability does not represent real food consumption, the presence of a certain food or drink (or its absence) may lead to its consumption. The high home availability of sugar-sweetened beverages within the São Paulo sample corroborates national Brazilian data, which show an increase in sugar-sweetened beverages consumption of almost 500% in a 30-year period.
34Instituto Brasileiro de Geografia e Estatística
National Household Budget Survey 2002–2003: Analyses on Household Food Availability and Nutrition Status in Brazil.
Data from a national research, National Dietary Survey, which tracks per capita consumption of foods and beverages in the Brazilian population, show that sugar-sweetened beverages are the fifth most commonly consumed item (94.7 g/d). Container sizes in grocery stores in Brazil are comparable to those in the US, ranging from 250 mL (8.4 oz) to 3.3 L (111.5 oz). Because sugar-sweetened beverages are high in energy and low in nutrients, and consumption has been found to be linked with obesity,
35- Wang Y.C.
- Ludwig D.S.
- Sonneville K.
- Gortmaker S.L.
Impact of change in sweetened caloric beverage consumption on energy intake among children and adolescents.
, 36- Ludwig D.S.
- Peterson K.E.
- Gortmaker S.L.
Relation between consumption of sugar-sweetened drinks and childhood obesity: a prospective, observational analysis.
, 37The role of sugar-sweetened beverage consumption in adolescent obesity: a review of the literature.
, 38- Fiorito L.M.
- Marini M.
- Francis L.A.
- Smiciklas-Wright H.
- Birch L.L.
Beverage intake of girls at age 5 y predicts adiposity and weight status in childhood and adolescence.
the inordinate home food availability of these beverages among São Paulo youth is of concern.
Aside from the high sugar-sweetened beverages availability within Brazilian adolescents' homes, findings indicated that the home food environments of participating adolescents were generally healthier in São Paulo than in St Paul–Minneapolis. For example, higher percentages of São Paulo youth reported usually or always having fruits and vegetables at home, and having milk and vegetables served at meals, compared with St Paul–Minneapolis youth. Home food availability does not guarantee that individuals are consuming foods and beverages present at home, but their presence may enhance consumption.
This study has several strengths and limitations that should be taken into account in interpreting the findings. Cross-cultural studies on food and nutrition issues are an important tool that could help understand factors that influence eating behavior and environmental variables through global and local perspectives. This type of analysis has the potential to identify new behaviors and risk factors for populations. To the authors' knowledge, this is the first study to assess such a breadth of nutrition-related factors among a large sample of Brazilian adolescents. For example, studies that have assessed the home food environment of São Paulo adolescents have not been developed. In addition, to the authors' knowledge, a comparison study between adolescent samples in Brazil and the US on eating behaviors and home food availability has not been done before. Because the São Paulo survey was based on Project EAT, identical measures were employed, which enhanced the ability to make cross-cultural comparisons. Findings provide important baseline information for future studies; however, because adolescents from only São Paulo and St Paul–Minneapolis were included in this study, findings may not be representative of national eating behaviors and home food environments in the 2 countries. An additional study limitation is that although both studies used similar survey items, the researchers checked the reliability of items and scales only in the Minnesotan sample, not in the Brazilian sample. Furthermore, a few variables were assessed differently in each country; for instance, dietary data, socioeconomic status, and race were not measured in the São Paulo sample. Thus, analyses did not adjust for possible differences in these variables across countries. Finally, these findings are cross-sectional and inferences about temporality or causality of relationships between variables cannot be drawn.
Implications for Research and Practice
This study assessed home food availability and environment and eating behaviors among adolescents from São Paulo, and compared findings with a sample of youth from St Paul–Minneapolis. As hypothesized, adolescents from São Paulo had healthier behaviors and healthier home food environments, which may reflect factors at the family and broader social and environmental levels, such as more traditional family structures and eating patterns, and social norms that are less supportive of fast food. Nutritionists and other health professionals working with youth in Brazil should encourage the maintenance of more traditional eating patterns because these patterns tend to be healthier compared with those of US youth examined in this study. For example, because having healthier foods at home has been found to predict greater consumption of fruits and vegetables in children,
39- Campbell K.J.
- Crawford D.A.
- Salmon J.
- Carver A.
- Garnett S.P.
- Baur L.A.
Associations between the home food environment and obesity-promoting eating behaviors in adolescence.
, 40- Hanson N.I.
- Neumark-Sztainer D.
- Eisenberg M.
- Story M.
- Wall M.
Associations between parental report of the home food environment and adolescent intakes of fruits, vegetables, and dairy foods.
, 41- Cullen K.W.
- Baranowski T.
- Owens E.
- Marsh T.
- Rittenberry L.
- de Moor C.
Availability, accessibility, and preferences for fruit, 100% fruit juice, and vegetables influence children’s dietary behavior.
nutritionists and health educators need to work to preserve these patterns among Brazilian households. Given the high energy and low nutrient density of sugar-sweetened beverages,
42- Malik V.S.
- Schulze M.B.
- Hu F.B.
Intake of sugar-sweetened beverages and weight gain: a systematic review.
the high presence of sugar-sweetened beverages in the homes of the Brazilian youth is of concern. Findings from the current study point to the importance of working with parents to increase their awareness about healthier alternatives to sugar-sweetened beverages. Families, especially mothers who tend to be the main actors during decision processes regarding foods and drinks to be purchased and consumed at home, may need to be sensitized about the consequences of the consistent presence of soft drinks at home. However, because of the pervasiveness of advertisements for sugar-sweetened beverages, it may not work with parents of youth. An integrated and joint action in different spheres, such as the family, schools, health professionals, and the government, should be developed to reduce the presence and consequent consumption of soda in this population. Additional research is needed regarding eating patterns, dietary intake, and home food availability in Brazilian youth. More globally, studies are needed to better assess the magnitude of the nutrition transition in developing countries, explore causal pathways, and test the effectiveness of intervention strategies within transitioning populations with emerging nutrition and weight-related problems.
Article info
Publication history
Published online: March 24, 2014
Accepted:
January 21,
2014
Copyright
© 2014 Society for Nutrition Education and Behavior. Published by Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.